The Phenomenology of Self-Estrangement: An Exhaustive Analysis of the Interrogative "What Have I Become?"
I. Introduction: The Locus of Existential Rupture
The interrogative phrase "What have I become?" serves as a linguistic marker for a profound psychological, narrative, and philosophical event: the realization of a severed continuity between a subject's past identity and their present reality. Unlike the adjacent query "What have I done?", which focuses on specific transgressions or actions, "What have I become?" addresses ontology—the state of being itself. It suggests a transformation that is totalizing, often irreversible, and typically viewed with horror, regret, or alienation. This report provides an exhaustive analysis of this existential query, tracing its resonance across music theory, narrative structure, Gothic literature, clinical psychology, and popular culture tropes.
The phrase implies a passive observation of an active decay; the speaker views themselves as a stranger, an "other" occupying their own skin. This dissociation is the core theme linking the varied manifestations of the phrase, from the industrial dissonance of Nine Inch Nails to the structural midpoints of Hollywood thrillers, and from the neurological illusions of mirror-gazing to the theological despair of fallen heroes. The investigation reveals that this question is not merely a dramatic flourish but a fundamental mechanism of human self-awareness, functioning as the threshold between integration and disintegration.
II. Sonic Dissonance: The Cultural Hegemony of "Hurt"
In contemporary culture, the question "What have I become?" is inextricably linked to the song "Hurt," originally written by Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails and famously covered by Johnny Cash. The song functions as the primary cultural vehicle for this specific existential dread, offering two distinct but complementary interpretations of self-estrangement: the nihilism of youth and the retrospective grief of old age.
The Industrial Nihilism of Nine Inch Nails
Trent Reznor composed "Hurt" for the 1994 album The Downward Spiral, a concept album detailing the destruction of a man who strips away every layer of his life, finding nothing beneath. In this context, the line "What have I become / My sweetest friend" is delivered as a whisper, an intimate confession of failure following a narrative of drug addiction, self-harm, and isolation. The "sweetest friend" is often interpreted as a personification of the depression or addiction itself—the only constant companion in the protagonist's "empire of dirt".
Reznor's version is rooted in the "transient myths of popular culture," using the landscape of postmodernity to critique the idea of progress. The "empire of dirt" represents the hollow victory of the protagonist's isolation; he has achieved the solitude he sought, only to find it worthless. The lyric "Everyone I know / Goes away in the end" in the original version reflects the transient nature of relationships in the face of mental illness and the solipsism of the addict. The delivery is characterized by ambient noise, mechanical discord, and a vocal performance that teeters on the edge of a breakdown, embodying the "societal landscape that arises from the wake of postmodernity".
The lyrics suggest a duality of the self: "You are someone else / I am still right here." This separation posits the "You" as the functioning, social self that has been lost or destroyed, while the "I" is the residual consciousness trapped in the wreckage. The song's conclusion, "If I could start again / A million miles away / I would keep myself," indicates that the loss of selfhood is the ultimate tragedy, surpassing the loss of material empire or social connection.
The Country Elegy: Johnny Cash's Recontextualization
When Johnny Cash covered "Hurt" in 2002 for American IV: The Man Comes Around, the semantic weight of the question "What have I become?" shifted from the prospective dread of a young man to the retrospective assessment of a dying legend. Cash was 71 years old, suffering from autonomic neuropathy, and nearing the end of his life. In his voice, the question became a meditation on the fragility of fame, the decay of the body, and the accumulation of loss.
The recontextualization was so potent that Reznor himself acknowledged the cover's transformative power, stating that the song "wasn't my song anymore" after seeing the video, which juxtaposed a "young, vibrant man" with the "Johnny near the end of his life". Cash's delivery transforms the "sweetest friend" from a metaphor for addiction into a reference to God, or perhaps the memory of his late wife, June Carter Cash (who appears in the video), looking on at the inevitable end.
The "empire of dirt" in Cash's version is not a metaphorical space of addiction but a literal reference to his material legacy—the gold records, the museum, the fame—which he realizes is ultimately meaningless in the face of mortality. This aligns with the "social model of disability" in literature, where the aging body becomes a site of cultural critique. The song becomes an elegy not just for a man, but for a vanishing era of American music and the "Man in Black" persona itself.
Musicological Deconstruction: The Tritone and the Unresolved Chord
The profound unsettling nature of the question "What have I become?" in "Hurt" is not merely lyrical but musicological. The composition relies on specific harmonic structures todirectly encode the sensation of self-estrangement in the listener's auditory cortex.
The Tritone Dissonance: The verse features a highly dissonant guitar interval. Specifically, the harmony oscillates between a B5 chord and an E# (enharmonically F) tritone. This B/E# dyad creates a sonic tension that mirrors the lyrical tension of the protagonist's shattered psyche. The tritone, historically known as diabolus in musica (the devil in music), is often used to convey ominous, dangerous situations and evoke fear and anxiety. In "Hurt," it functions as the musical embodiment of the "abject" self.
Melodic Stress: Reznor emphasizes this dissonance by singing the eleventh note of the scale on the word "I" every time the dissonant dyad is played. This aligns the concept of the "I" (the self) with the musical dissonance, effectively encoding the self-estrangement into the melody itself. The singer literally cannot find a "home" note, mirroring the psychological homelessness of the lyrics.
Lack of Resolution: Music theorists note that the song creates a "sonic question mark." Unlike traditional progressions that resolve to a tonic home, the chord structure of "Hurt" cycles through tension without providing the release of a perfect cadence.
Verse Progression: A minor, C, D. This progression avoids the dominant chord that would pull the ear back to the tonic, creating a sense of wandering.
Chorus Progression: A minor, F major 7, C, G. While the chorus introduces a G major chord, which could lead to a resolution, it instead loops back to the minor tension.
The Ending: The song ends on a lingering, distorted noise rather than a clean chord, leaving the question "What have I become?" hanging in the air, unanswered.
Visual Analysis: The Cinema of Decay
The music video for Johnny Cash's "Hurt," directed by Mark Romanek, visually anchors the retrospective interpretation of the lyric. It utilizes a sophisticated editing strategy to create a "social model of disability" and aging, framing the question "What have I become?" as a confrontation with physical decline.
The Banquet of Vanitas: Romanek films Cash sitting at a banquet table laden with rotting fruit and flowers. This is a direct reference to the vanitas tradition in art history—still-life paintings meant to remind viewers of life's transience (memento mori). The visual decay of the fruit parallels the decay of Cash's body and the derelict state of the House of Cash museum.
Montage of Loss: The video employs a montage technique that juxtaposes archival footage of a young, powerful Cash with the frail singer's present reality.
The Trains: Footage of Cash riding trains and performing to adoring crowds highlights the vitality that has been lost.
The Broken Empire: Images of cracked platinum records, broken glass, and the piano's closed lid serve as literal representations of the "empire of dirt." The closed piano lid, which Cash gently touches, symbolizes the finality of his career—the music has stopped.
Religious Imagery: Scenes of Jesus carrying the cross and the crucifixion are intercut with Cash's suffering, elevating his personal pain to a spiritual passion play. This aligns with the "crown of thorns" (or "crown of shit" in the NIN version) lyric, reinforcing the dual aspect of sinner and savior.
The editing is fast-paced, using jump cuts to connect these disparities, creating a sense of a life flashing before one's eyes. The high-key lighting in certain shots emphasizes the deep lines in Cash's face, refusing to hide the ravages of time.
III. Narrative Mechanics: The Mirror Moment in Storytelling
In the craft of storytelling, "What have I become?" is not just dialogue; it is a structural necessity known as the "Mirror Moment." This concept, popularized by writing instructor James Scott Bell, posits that in the middle of a narrative (the midpoint), the protagonist must metaphorically or literally look at themselves and assess their transformation.
Structural Theory: The Midpoint of Transformation
The Mirror Moment serves as the psychological pivot of a story. It occurs when the protagonist moves from a reactive state (running from the problem) to a proactive state (attacking the problem), but this shift requires a moment of deep existential assessment. This structural beat is often placed exactly at the 50% mark of a film or novel.
The Two Types of Mirror Moments:
The Internal Gaze: The character looks at themselves and asks, "Who am I? What have I become? Am I going to stay this way?" This applies to characters facing moral corruption or spiritual death. It is an "internal gaze" where the protagonist realizes they are losing their humanity.
The External Gaze: The character looks at their situation and thinks, "I'm probably going to die. There's no way I can survive this." This applies to action thrillers where the physical stakes are paramount. The "What have I become?" here is a realization of reduced agency or resources.
This moment forces the character to confront the cost of their journey. If they do not ask "What have I become?", the subsequent actions lack emotional weight. The question signifies that the "old self" is dead or dying, and a "new self" must emerge to finish the story. The "Doorway of No Return" has slammed shut, and they must face the "dark forest" of the second half of the narrative.
Case Study: The Fugitive and the External Gaze
In the film The Fugitive (1993), the Mirror Moment occurs precisely at the halfway point. Dr. Richard Kimble (Harrison Ford), stripped of his status as a respected surgeon and branded a murderer, creates a fake ID to infiltrate a hospital and find the one-armed man.
The Scene: Kimble is in a rented basement room. He has dyed his hair, shaved his beard, and altered his appearance to become a janitor. He looks in the mirror and does not recognize the man staring back.
The Implication: While Kimble does not speak the line "What have I become?" aloud, the visual language conveys the question. He has become a fugitive, a liar, and a criminal in the eyes of the law to prove his innocence. The mirror reflection confirms the death of Dr. Kimble and the birth of the desperate survivor. The scene serves as a "Doorway of No Return" confirmation: he cannot return to his ordinary life. The external pressure of the U.S. Marshals forces this internal reconfiguration.
Case Study: Breaking Bad and the Moral Event Horizon
The television series Breaking Bad is essentially a 62-episode exploration of the question "What have I become?" applied to the character of Walter White. The series charts his transformation from a mild-mannered chemistry teacher to the ruthless drug lord Heisenberg.
The Moment of Recognition: Bryan Cranston, in his memoir A Life in Parts, identifies a specific moment during the filming of the Season 2 episode "Phoenix" where this question became tangible. In the scene, Walt watches Jesse Pinkman's girlfriend, Jane, choke to death on her own vomit and chooses not to save her.
Internal Monologue vs. Script: While the script did not require Walt to say the words, Cranston describes his internal acting process in vivid detail. He recalls an internal monologue in which Walt justifies his inaction: "She's a junkie... she'll drag Jesse down." But then, the human realization strikes: "But I am here. And she's a human being. Oh God. What have I become?"
The Projection of Self: Cranston notes that in that moment, he saw his own daughter's face superimposed on the actress Krysten Ritter. The horror of "What have I become?" arose from the collision of his real identity (a father) and his character's identity (a murderer by omission). This illustrates how the question functions as a mechanism for the actor to access the depth of the character's depravity.
Narrative Consequences: This moment is the "Moral Event Horizon." By suppressing the answer to "What have I become?"—by justifying the death as necessary for self-preservation—Walt completes his transformation into Heisenberg. Later seasons see other characters, like Skyler White and Jesse Pinkman, asking similar questions as they are pulled into Walt's "empire of dirt." Skyler eventually becomes an accomplice, realizing too late that she has normalized evil.
IV. Literary Genealogy: The Gothic and the Absurd
Long before it was a lyric or a screenwriting term, the anxiety of "What have I become?" was a staple of Gothic and Existentialist literature. In these genres, the question addresses the "abject"—that which disturbs identity, system, and order.
Frankenstein and the Abject Reflection
Mary Shelley's Frankenstein (1818) is the foundational text for the "What have I become?" trope, particularly regarding the monstrous body.
The Lacanian Mirror Stage Gone Wrong: The Creature's development mimics that of the human infant, but the moment of self-recognition is traumatic rather than integrative. When the Creature sees his reflection in a pool of water, he does not see a unified "I" but a monster. He is "fully convinced that I was in reality the monster that I am," leading to "bitterest sensations of despondence".
Textual Analysis: While the exact phrase "What have I become?" is often attributed to the Creature in pop culture adaptations, the text focuses on variations of this sentiment. The Creature asks, "Who was I? What was I? Whence did I come?" (Vol. II, Chapter 5). Literary scholars analyze this as a crisis of "bodily ownership".
The Multiplicitous Subject: Eleanor Salotto argues that Frankenstein articulates a subject that is "multiple and shifting." The Creature is a "filthy mass that moved and talked," an assembly of dead parts. His question "What have I become?" (or "What was I?") reflects the horror of being a composite being without a singular origin. He is a "body without a center," challenging the very notion of the Enlightenment subject.
Modern Reinterpretations: In adaptations like the play Monstress, the character Sydney Williams asks, "What have I become?" upon realizing her ambition has turned her into a god-like figure of hubris, mirroring Victor Frankenstein. This shifts the question from the monster to the creator, highlighting that the true monstrosity is often the intellectual detachment that allows for the creation of the abject.
Sartre's Nausea: The Horror of Contingency
In Jean-Paul Sartre's novel Nausea, the protagonist Roquentin experiences the question "What have I become?" not as a moral crisis, but as an ontological one. This is the existential horror of "contingency"—the realization that existence has no necessary purpose.
The Face as Landscape: Roquentin looks in the mirror and fails to recognize himself as a human subject. He describes his face as a "grey thing," a "clod of earth," or a "block of stone". The reflection loses its semantic meaning; it is no longer a "face" but simply biological matter.
Alienation from the Ego: He states, "I can understand nothing of this face... I cannot even decide whether it is handsome or ugly. I think it is ugly because I have been told so". This radical dissociation strips away the social mask, leaving only the terrifying "stuff" of existence.
The Answer: For Sartre, the answer to "What have I become?" is "Nothingness." The protagonist realizes that the "I" is a construct, and beneath it lies only raw, terrifying existence. This aligns with the "depersonalization" discussed in psychological sections, where the "impersonality absorbs consciousness".
Kafkaesque Metamorphosis: Physicality as Metaphor
Franz Kafka's The Metamorphosis literalizes the question. Gregor Samsa wakes up transformed into a "monstrous vermin."
The Unasked Question: Interestingly, Gregor rarely asks "What have I become?" in a panic. Instead, he worries about missing his train. The horror lies in the absence of the question; he accepts his new state with disturbing passivity. This acceptance suggests that he had already become a vermin—a mindless worker—long before the physical transformation occurred.
External vs. Internal: The question is shifted to the family, who look at Gregor and ask, in essence, "What has he become?" The transformation is a physical manifestation of his prior dehumanization as a "cog in the wheel" of capitalism and familial duty.
V. Psychological and Neurological Underpinnings
The sensation of looking in a mirror and asking "What have I become?" is not merely a literary device; it is a documented neurological and psychological phenomenon.
The Strange-Face-in-the-Mirror Illusion (Caputo Effect)
In 2010, psychologist Giovanni Caputo published research on the "Strange-Face-in-the-Mirror" illusion. He found that when people stare into their own eyes in a mirror in dim lighting for a sustained period (usually over a minute), their perception of their own face begins to distort.
Data compiled from Caputo (2010) and subsequent replication studies.
Mechanism: This illusion is thought to be caused by the "Troxler Effect" (fading of peripheral vision due to neural adaptation) combined with the brain's "top-down" processing. When visual information degrades in dim light, the brain attempts to "fill in" missing data, often drawing on subconscious fears or memories.
Relevance to Query: This explains why the mirror is the central locus for the question "What have I become?" The neurological instability of the reflection provides a canvas for the subject to project their internal psychological state—seeing a "monster" or a "stranger" where their face should be. The illusion literalizes the internal feeling of self-estrangement.
Pathologies of the Self: Depersonalization and Derealization
The clinical condition known as Depersonalization-Derealization Disorder (DPDR) involves a chronic sensation of the question "What have I become?"
Depersonalization: The feeling of being an outside observer of one's thoughts or body. Patients report feeling "robotic," "not in control," or that their physical features (hands, face) are distorted or not their own.
Mirror Sign: A specific symptom where patients look in the mirror and feel zero emotional connection to the reflection. They intellectually know it is them, but emotionally feel they are looking at a stranger. This effectively makes the question "What have I become?" a daily reality rather than a dramatic moment.
Etiology: This state often arises as a defense mechanism against trauma or severe anxiety. The brain "disconnects" the "I" from the "Me" to protect the psyche from overwhelming pain. Thus, "What have I become?" is the conscious mind trying to bridge the gap created by this dissociation.
Jungian Integration: The Shadow Self
Carl Jung's psychology offers a framework for "What have I become?" as a necessary stage of individuation—the process of becoming a whole person.
The Shadow: The "Shadow" consists of the repressed, unacceptable parts of the personality (aggression, lust, weakness). It is the "empire of dirt" that the conscious ego tries to hide.
The Confrontation: When a person asks, "What have I become?", they are often encountering their Shadow for the first time. In "Hurt," the "liar's chair" and "crown of shit" are confrontations with the Shadow aspects of the self (the addict, the deceiver) that can no longer be repressed.
Integration vs. Possession: The goal in Jungian therapy is to integrate the Shadow (acknowledge it is part of "I"). If one fails, one becomes "possessed" by the Shadow—becoming the monster they fear. The question "What have I become?" marks the threshold between integration (healing) and possession (destruction). In stories like The Fugitive, the protagonist integrates the Shadow (the criminal skills) to survive; in Breaking Bad, the protagonist is possessed by it.
VI. Trope and Meme: The Diffusion of Existential Dread in Popular Media
The phrase has diffused from high art and clinical psychology into the vernacular of pop culture, where it often dilutes its horror into melodrama or humor.
The "Heel Realization" and Villainy
In narrative tropes, "What have I become?" is the stock phrase for the "Heel Realization" (when a bad guy realizes they are bad).
The Formula: A character commits an atrocity, usually hurting a loved one, and then looks at their hands or a reflection and utters the line.
Examples:
Anakin Skywalker / Darth Vader: In Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith, Anakin's turn is cemented by his actions against Mace Windu. While he asks "What have I done?" in the film, the cultural memory often conflates this with "What have I become?" due to his total transformation into Vader—"more machine than man."
Kratos (God of War): The protagonist Kratos asks, "By the gods, what have I become?" after realizing his blind rage has led him to kill his own family. This moment drives the entire franchise's narrative of seeking redemption (or oblivion). He sees himself as a "monster" that can only destroy.
Spider-Man (Symbiote Suit): In various iterations (comics, Spider-Man 3), Peter Parker realizes the black suit is making him aggressive. He looks in a mirror (often shattered) and asks the question before tearing the suit off. This is a literal "shedding" of the negative becoming.
Prototypes and Mutants: In the game Prototype, Alex Mercer asks, "What have I become? Something less than human... but also something more," embracing the monstrosity as evolution rather than degradation.
Digital Trivialization: The "What Have I Become" Meme
In the internet era, the phrase has been repurposed as a meme, stripping it of its existential weight and applying it to trivial situations.
The Cat in the Mirror: A popular meme format involves a cat standing on its hind legs looking into a mirror. Captions often overlay the lyrics from "Hurt" ("What have I become / My sweetest friend") or internal monologues about being "just a slave to catnip" or "nothing more than a plush for these giant lumbering creatures".
The Function of the Meme: This usage highlights the absurdity of the "Mirror Moment." By projecting deep existential dread onto an animal that likely lacks the capacity for such complex self-reflection (though cats do not pass the mirror test, they react to reflections), the meme satirizes human melodrama. It allows users to express low-stakes regret (e.g., eating too much, procrastinating) through the hyperbolic language of tragic downfall.
Consumerism as Identity Crisis: In online discussions, the phrase is also used ironically to describe consumerist regret. For example, a user buys an expensive replica jacket from a video game and asks, "What have I become?"—not because they have lost their soul, but because they have succumbed to nerdy consumerism. The community responds not with philosophical comfort but with requests for the purchase link, further trivializing the crisis.
VII. Synthesis and Conclusion: The Persistence of the Question
The question "What have I become?" endures because it is the ultimate articulation of human plasticity, unlike animals, which largely remain what they are born as; humans transform. We age, we learn, we corrupt, and we redeem. The phrase serves as a checkpoint in this fluidity, a moment where the consciousness attempts to freeze the flux of time and judge the result.
The analysis reveals that this question is rarely asked in triumph. In the music of Cash and Reznor, it is a confession of loss—of youth, of friends, of the "empire" of the ego. In the structure of The Fugitive and Breaking Bad, it is a pivot point between survival and damnation, a "Doorway of No Return" that must be crossed. In the psychology of the mirror, it is the brain failing to recognize its own vessel, a glitch in the self-simulation that reveals the frightening malleability of identity.
Whether whispered in an industrial rock song, screamed by a tragic villain, experienced as a clinical symptom of dissociation, or captioned on a picture of a startled cat, "What have I become?" remains the defining query of the self that has lost its way home. It is an acknowledgment that the "I" is not a fixed point, but a trajectory—and often, one that has veered terrifyingly off course. The persistence of the phrase across such diverse domains—from 19th-century Gothic literature to 21st-century memes—demonstrates that the fear of becoming a stranger to oneself is a universal human constant, transcending time, genre, and medium.
No comments:
Post a Comment